PREPARATION FILMS • BLOG

Watching a Movie Like a Filmmaker

How the creative decisions affect the story.

By Kristina Robison — Preparation Films

Most people watch movies like an audience member. They watch for the story. They want to know what happens next. They want to feel what the film wants them to feel. And why wouldn’t they? That is a perfectly reasonable way to watch a movie. It is not, however, the only way. You can also watch movies like a filmmaker.

A filmmaker watches movies for the choices that are made. And let’s be clear, every shot is a choice. Every cut is a choice. The music, the casting, the framing — someone made a choice about each and every one of those things. Watching like a filmmaker means looking at what those choices are trying to convey and deciding whether or not it worked.

How do you do that? Well, I’m glad you asked. I have a short set of questions I drafted for my upcoming film ministry students. They’ll answer them when they watch a movie. Here are some of the questions: Choose a role to focus on today — for example, the DP, the screenwriter, the gaffer, the sound recordist, or the editor. Was there a choice that stood out — the camera, the script, the lighting, the sound, the editing? If you were hired in that role, would you keep it exactly the same as you saw it? Would you change anything? Why would you make that choice? Is there any moment or scene that stood out? What and why? Was there anything that made you uncomfortable? What, and why? Did anything feel unnecessary, or just for shock value? How did they handle difficult content? These questions work for anyone who wants to watch a film this way.

What is this film trying to get me to feel?

A film tells you how to feel before you have time to think about it. The music swells before the sad scene. The camera moves in close on a face. The villain gets a certain kind of light and a certain kind of music, and you know how you’re supposed to feel about them before they say a word.

None of that is an accident. When you feel something in a scene — good or bad, anything — stop and name it. Then ask whether that was the intended point of the scene. What emotion did the filmmaker want to evoke? What did they want you to start thinking about without noticing it? Look at the music, the camera, and the lighting, and you can usually tell. Noticing the feeling doesn't mean you can't feel it; it just means you know what direction they’re pointing you in.

Start paying attention to how the camera looks at people. When it's looking up at someone (called a low angle shot), that person can look stronger and larger than life. When the camera looks down at someone (high angle), that person can look weaker, smaller, or more frightened. Some camera angles can also be meant to leave you feeling disoriented or uneasy. Those are all choices, and they shape what you feel before you have time to think consciously about it.

What does this film treat as ‘the norm’?

Watch for what the film treats as good, what it treats as funny, and what it treats as normal or acceptable. Watch for who gets to be the hero and who or what gets laughed at. Watch for what gets rewarded and what gets punished. This isn’t often stated out loud. It's shown, scene after scene after scene. The film is teaching you how it wants you to look at its world — and what perspective to look from. That, again, is a choice. And when you watch for those choices, you start to see the film's end goal.

What stays with me after the credits?

This question is really important. After the film ends, think about what it made you feel while watching it. Were you uncomfortable? Was it exciting? Were you happy?

Name that feeling. Then ask yourself if it stayed with you. Think about it. Was there a line you repeated, something you now see differently, or a feeling that lingered into the next day? Be honest about it. That step right there will help you become a better filmmaker. You’ll be able to point to the choices that were made in the film, and recognize the effects those choices had.

Did it seem purposeful?

Last, ask whether it seemed purposeful. Did the filmmaker think about the effect the film was having on the people watching it? You can't know for certain. But you can look at the choices that were made. When the perspective, the lighting, the music, all point in the same direction, that doesn't happen by accident.

Seeing the choices (I know, I know — that word again) can make a good film better, because you begin to appreciate how much work went into every decision.

Watch a story, and then watch how choices (last time, really) are made to tell that story. That's how you watch like a filmmaker.


Last week’s post: A Film Influences Its Makers, Too.

The free Responsible Filmmaking Guide is a practical introduction to the framework — it walks through deciding the purpose of a story, who it's for, and how it may influence the people who watch it.