PREPARATION FILMS • BLOG

A Film Influences Its Makers, Too

Influence runs in more than one direction.

By Kristina Robison — Preparation Films

Last week, I followed a story's influence as it travels outward — from one person who watches, to their circle, to a community, to a whole society. This week, I want to look in the other direction. Long before a story reaches an audience, it spends months with the people making it. And here's the thing: it does not leave them unchanged.

We tend to talk about a film's influence as something that begins at the premiere. It doesn't. It begins in development, in the casting room, on the set, and in the edit — with the people closest to the material. A film's responsibility is not only to the people who will watch it. Its responsibility is to the people who make it, and to the people whose lives it tells.

What does a story do to the people who make it?

The crew spends months making the story. Actors rehearse their parts until the words come easily, editors watch the same footage again and again, and designers build the world of the story. Whatever a film draws its audience into for 2 hours, it draws its makers into for months.

But the effects of that experience don't end when the cameras stop rolling. The material we work with, the scenes we repeatedly perform or watch, and the environments we create can affect us in ways we may not recognize at the time. As responsible filmmakers, we have to consider how the process of making a story influences the people involved—not just how the finished film influences the audience.

And that constant exposure does something to people. Just imagine, if a film influences an audience in a single viewing, what it can do to the makers who are with it for so long.

There is research on this. In 2014, researchers studied 116 journalists whose job was reviewing graphic, violent footage sent in to three international news organizations. The journalists who viewed that material most frequently showed higher levels of anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress — and it was the frequency of the viewing, more than the length of any single viewing, that amplified the harm. Documentary editors do the same kind of work. They may spend hours going through footage of suffering, deciding what stays. And it is not only editors. The whole crew works with that material, day after day, for an extended period of time.

But we have begun to answer this. Tonia Sina coined the term "intimacy choreographer" for theater. For film and television they're called an intimacy coordinator. "An advocate, a liaison between actors and production...in regards to...intimate and hyper-exposed scenes." In 2016 Ms. Sina, Alicia Rodis, and Siobhan Richardson founded Intimacy Directors International, the first company to train people for the work. It reached television in 2018, when Emily Meade asked for someone whose job was the intimate scenes, the way a stunt coordinator's job is the stunts, and HBO hired Rodis — the first time a television series had done that. That same year HBO made it standard on every production with intimate scenes. Since then, it has spread across the industry, and the intimacy coordinator is now an accepted industry standard. The making affects the makers, so the care has to be built into the process — the way safety is already built in for stunts, for children, and for animals on a set.

Think about how important this is for stunt performers. A stunt coordinator plans the fall, the fight or the crash on set, and the performer does it. SAG-AFTRA requires a qualified coordinator on any production with stunts, and that coordinator's job is to keep the performer safe. But sometimes a filmmaker wants the shot so badly they stop paying attention to what's important. They push to rush a take. They try to talk the coordinator, or the performer, into doing something that isn't exactly 'up to code'. Maybe they want a better angle, maybe they want to hurry the shot along. But no shot is worth somebody's life or well-being. You don't take chances with safety. You don't work safety around your shot, you build your shot around what's safe.

Unfortunately the outcome of taking those chances isn't hypothetical. There are many examples of stunt performers losing their lives on stunts where someone had already questioned the safety, and it went ahead anyway. In short, there are many examples of heartbreak that did not have to happen.

A production that takes its cast and crew for granted can put people at risk in ways that go beyond the normal demands of the job. A makeup artist may be expected to share makeup products between cast members or use products with irritating ingredients or fumes, putting both the people wearing them and the artist applying them at risk of skin reactions or other adverse effects. Or an actor may spend hours portraying someone experiencing abuse or grief, repeatedly returning to an emotionally difficult place to get the performance a scene requires. A crew member may spend weeks filming disturbing scenes, listening to dialogue, or watching the same acts of violence take place over and over. Someone working on a story involving traumatic experiences may find that the material stays with them even after filming is done. Not everyone will respond the same way, but we shouldn't assume that because someone is doing their job, the work has no effect on them. These are reminders that the people making a film are human beings, affected by both the circumstances of production and the material they're working with. Unsafe conditions can lead to injury. Repeated exposure to emotionally difficult material can take a toll, too. A film is responsible to all of them – the people in front of the camera, the people moving the lights, applying the makeup, and performing the stunts.

None of this is an argument against telling difficult stories. It's an argument for knowing what the creating of the story may ask of the people developing it, and deciding before the shoot how they will be cared for while they do it.

What do we owe the people whose stories we tell?

Some stories we make up. Other stories we borrow from someone else's life: someone's worst moment, a town's tragedy, a community's traditions. These can all give the story its framework.

When the film is finished, everyone else goes home. But the person portrayed is still living their life, as the film described, now with a version of it fixed in public perception.

What responsibility asks us to do here isn't complicated. We tell the truth about someone we're representing. We talk to the people our story comes from before we shoot, while we can still get it right. That is also responsible filmmaking. And we remember that the portrayal will outlive the production by years: it can follow a person into job interviews, into their church, into their children's classrooms. A filmmaker can potentially spend a few months deciding what a real person may be known by for the rest of their life. For good or not so good. That consequence is reason enough to handle it with care.

What do our choices tell people about us?

There is one more person a film influences, and it is the one making it.

The choices we make repeatedly shape us. What we practice considering, we get better at considering. What we practice excusing, we get better at excusing. A filmmaker who has decided a hundred times that the interesting looking shot doesn't justify negligence will reach for that answer faster the hundred-and-first time. Our habits train us.

And those choices do not stay private. The choices we make repeatedly also affect how people see us. They tell others what kind of filmmaker we are and as a consequence whether or not we're someone they can trust.

People draw that conclusion from evidence: how we handle the vulnerable scenes, how we treat the real person's story, what we do with the power we have on set. And no one will announce their verdict to your face. They'll just make a decision. A subject will decide whether to trust us with the true version of events. A collaborator will decide whether to come back. A funder will decide whether our name means the work will be handled with care. And trust will decide what stories we will be allowed to tell next.

A filmmaker known for operating with care and integrity will get told things a careless filmmaker will never hear. Doors will open to the first kind of filmmaker, and they close to the second; usually quietly, and many times for good. Our reputation is not separate from what we do. Our reputation is the record of our choices, and others are keeping those records whether we know it or not.

Responsibility covers everyone the film touches

So the picture is wider than the audience. Our work affects the people who watch it, the people whose lives and experiences we represent, and the crew who bring the story to life. And we are responsible for making sure that affect is, to the best of our ability, never harmful. That's what it means to be a responsible filmmaker.

Like I've said before, we have influence whether we know it or not, whether we acknowledge it or not. That is true in the movie theater, and it's just as true on the set where the film is made.

Sources

  • Feinstein, A., Audet, B., & Waknine, E., "Witnessing images of extreme violence: a psychological study of journalists in the newsroom" — JRSM Open, 2014
  • HBO's intimacy coordinator policy for all productions with intimate scenes, first reported by Rolling Stone — October 2018
  • Intimacy for Stage and Screen, "Guidelines for Engaging Intimacy Directors for Live Performance" — on the theater origins of intimacy direction and the 2016 founding of Intimacy Directors International
  • Wikipedia, "Intimacy coordinator" — definition of an intimacy coordinator as an advocate and liaison between actors and production

Last week's post: How Films Shape Society.

The free Responsible Filmmaking Guide is a practical introduction to the framework — it walks through deciding the purpose of a story, who it's for, and how it may influence the people who watch it.